Scoring Criteria
1. Importance [All formats] (0-5 points):
Innovation, relevance, creativity, new or cutting edge information,
originality of approaches/interventions, significance or interest to
the audience.
2a. Methodology [Format I] (0-5 points):
Appropriateness of conceptual basis and design for the identified
purpose of the study, appropriateness of the data collection
techniques, development stage (level of data collection
completeness). -OR-
2b. Lessons Learned [Format II] (0-5 points):
Appropriateness of conceptual basis and design for the activity,
extent to which the lessons learned advance the state of the art of
HIV prevention, merit of the conclusions.
3. Clarity [All formats] (0-5 points):
Development of ideas and findings; communication of ideas and
findings.
4. Overall [All formats] (0-5 points):
Reject (0 points); Poor (1 point); Fair (2 points); Good (3 points);
Excellent (4 points); or Outstanding (5 points).
|
